Skip to content

Benchmark Testing

Testing dBSea’s Solvers in Multiple Comparisons with Well-Known Benchmark Problems

Section titled “Testing dBSea’s Solvers in Multiple Comparisons with Well-Known Benchmark Problems”

We here present solutions to a range of well-defined underwater sound propagation calculation problems for the comparison of dBSea’s algorithms to the open-source method based on the same modelling approach.

Many of the examples will link to “UWA” files. These are dBSea scenario files that can be viewed in dBSea BASIC (freely available from: dBSeaBasic-236.zip).

Please note that while ray tracing methods have been included in this document for the sake of completeness, they are generally not suitable for low-frequency problems (wavelength > 1–3% of depth).

The ASA Benchmark problems (Jensen & Ferla, 1989) represent a classic base for comparison of propagation modelling. The UWA file for this scenario is available from: UWA File

Image 1. Schematic of scenario for wedge problem Schematic of the ASA wedge benchmark: a 25 Hz source at 100 m depth, receivers at 30 m and 150 m, and a seabed sloping at 2.86° from 200 m depth to the surface at 4 km.

The following results are based on a comparison of dBSea’s solvers with solvers from the AcTUP toolbox (AcTUP Toolbox), covering two of the most popular methods of calculating the sound field, namely:

  • Parabolic Equation Method – dBSeaPE & RAM
  • Ray Tracing Method – dBSeaRay & Bellhop

Note that the scenario is modelled for 25 Hz. At this frequency, we do not expect the two ray tracing methods to work well.


Image 2. Transmission losses for dBSeaPE and RAM. Depths 30 m and 150 m are shown in chart, while full transects in colour are presented below. Chart and colour transects comparing dBSeaPE and RAM transmission loss over 4 km of the wedge problem at 30 m and 150 m depth.


Image 4. Transmission losses for dBSeaRay and Bellhop. Depths 30 m and 150 m are shown in chart, while full transects in colour (-20 dB to -70 dB) are presented below. Chart and colour transects comparing dBSeaRay and Bellhop transmission loss over 4 km of the wedge problem at 30 m and 150 m depth.

Note that neither of the ray tracing methods penetrate the sediment, and so the receiver depth at 150 m terminates shortly after a range of 1000 m. Notice that dBSeaRay reproduces the results well from the parabolic equation method, despite being unsuitable for the chosen frequency (25 Hz).


2.1 Parabolic Equation Workshop II 1993 – Case II

Section titled “2.1 Parabolic Equation Workshop II 1993 – Case II”

An upslope-downslope problem formulated to test the energy conservation in strongly range-dependent environments was formulated in (Chin-Bing et al., 1993). The UWA file for this scenario is available at: UWA File

Image 5. Schematic outlining upslope-downslope problem. Schematic of the upslope-downslope benchmark: a 25 Hz source at 100 m depth in 200 m of water, with the seabed rising to 25 m depth at 3.5 km and falling again by 7 km.


Image 6. Transmission losses for dBSeaPE and RAM. Depths 20 m and 150 m are shown in chart, while full transects in colour are presented below. Chart and colour transects comparing dBSeaPE and RAM transmission loss over 7 km of the upslope-downslope problem at 20 m and 150 m depth.


The Pekeris problem is a horizontally flat waveguide, designed to test propagation in an environment with a moderately absorbent sediment. See here for details about the Pekeris Problem

Schematic of the Pekeris problem: a 25 Hz source and receiver at 100 m depth in a flat 200 m waveguide over an absorbent seabed, with water and seabed properties listed.


Image 9. Transmission losses for dBSeaPE and RAM. Depth 100 m is shown in chart, while full transects in colour are presented below. Chart and colour transects comparing dBSeaPE and RAM transmission loss over 5 km of the Pekeris problem at 100 m depth.


Image 11. Transmission losses for dBSeaRay and Bellhop. Depth 100 m is shown in chart, while full transects in colour are presented below. Chart and colour transects comparing dBSeaRay and Bellhop transmission loss over 5 km of the Pekeris problem at 100 m depth.


  • Chin-Bing, S. A., King, D. B., Davis, J. A., & Evans, R. B. (1993). PE Workshop II. Stennis: Naval Research Laboratory.
  • Jensen, F. B., & Ferla, C. M. (1990). Numerical solutions of range-dependent benchmark problems in ocean acoustics. Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, 87(4), 1499–1510.